TL;DR
Get coffee and tea gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn food editor Ali Domrongchai says Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese was the closest match to McDonald’s Egg McMuffin in a weeklong taste test of 12 frozen sandwiches from five brands. The Kitchn reported prices of $8 for four Jimmy Dean sandwiches and $4.89 for one McDonald’s sandwich, though prices can vary by location and retailer.
The Kitchn food editor Ali Domrongchai named Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese her preferred frozen stand-in for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin after eating 12 breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week. Her report said a four-pack cost $8, compared with $4.89 for one McDonald’s sandwich at the time she bought it, although those prices are not a nationwide price comparison.
Domrongchai said the Jimmy Dean sandwich came closest to the fast-food version because both use an English muffin, egg, cheddar cheese and sausage. In her taste test, she described the frozen sandwich as less greasy while retaining flavor. She praised its juicy sausage, soft egg and sharp, gooey cheese. Those are her personal tasting impressions, not results from a controlled or blind test.
The sandwiches are not identical. Domrongchai noted that Jimmy Dean’s sausage includes chicken mixed with pork, while the McDonald’s sandwich uses a different sausage. The frozen sandwich has a scrambled egg patty; the restaurant version she compared it with has a whole egg with a firm yolk. The differences in ingredients and preparation mean the result is a substitute, not an exact copy.
At the reported prices, the Jimmy Dean four-pack works out to $2 per sandwich, before any tax. Domrongchai compared that with the $4.89 price she paid for the Egg McMuffin. She also reported that a McDonald’s meal with a hash brown and coffee cost $7.29. These figures reflect her purchases and the time of publication; the report does not establish that the same prices apply elsewhere or remain current.
A Lower-Cost Freezer Option
The comparison speaks to a practical choice for people who want a quick breakfast sandwich without making a restaurant stop. At the prices in Domrongchai’s report, the four-pack offers a lower per-sandwich price than the Egg McMuffin she bought, and keeping sandwiches in the freezer may make breakfast easier to plan. The cost difference could matter to shoppers who buy breakfast regularly, but the report does not calculate long-term savings or compare nutrition, portion sizes, or the total cost of preparing the sandwiches.
The review is also useful because it names the trade-offs behind the recommendation. Readers seeking an English muffin, sausage, egg and cheese combination may find the frozen option similar, while those who specifically prefer a whole egg or McDonald’s sausage may notice the distinctions. The conclusion reflects one editor’s personal taste test, not a broad consumer survey or an official product ranking.
Jimmy Dean English Muffin Egg and Cheese frozen breakfast sandwiches
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Sandwiches Were Compared
Domrongchai’s test followed her search for a convenient alternative to the Egg McMuffin, which she said she enjoys but finds costly at the price she encountered. Over one week, she ate a dozen frozen sandwiches from five brands. The report mentions options from Trader Joe’s as well as Jimmy Dean, but the supplied account does not list every product tested or provide a scoring system.
The Kitchn has previously published a related comparison: according to the report, contributor Kate had selected Jimmy Dean’s Sausage, Egg and Cheese Biscuit as a lower-cost match for McDonald’s biscuit sandwich. That earlier recommendation involved a different sandwich and is separate from Domrongchai’s English muffin test. The current article’s conclusion is specifically about her preferred match for the Egg McMuffin.
“The closest to my favorite McDonald’s one”
— Ali Domrongchai, The Kitchn associate editor of groceries
Prices and Taste Vary
The report does not provide the exact date of publication in the supplied material, the locations where the items were purchased, or a broader price survey. Its $8 four-pack and $4.89 restaurant sandwich figures should be treated as prices observed by the reviewer, not fixed or current prices for all markets. The article also does not provide a nutritional comparison, ingredient-by-ingredient analysis, or blind-test results.
It is not clear whether every sandwich was prepared according to identical instructions, or how the other tested products ranked. The comparison was based on one reviewer’s experience, so individual preferences, local availability and preparation may affect whether readers agree with the pick.
Check Local Prices and Labels
Readers considering the frozen sandwich can check current grocery prices and the package for ingredients, nutrition information and preparation directions. The Kitchn report does not announce a follow-up test or a wider review, so no further results are confirmed. Any future comparison would need updated local prices and clearly stated tasting criteria to show whether the same product remains the editor’s preferred match.
Key Questions
Which frozen sandwich did The Kitchn reviewer prefer?
Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese was Ali Domrongchai’s preferred match for a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin in her taste test.
How many sandwiches did the reviewer try?
Domrongchai said she ate 12 breakfast sandwiches from five brands over the course of a week.
How did the prices compare in the report?
The reviewer reported paying $8 for four Jimmy Dean sandwiches and $4.89 for one McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. Prices vary, and these were the amounts she encountered when publishing her report.
Are the Jimmy Dean and McDonald’s sandwiches identical?
No. They share an English muffin, egg, cheese and sausage, but the report says Jimmy Dean uses a scrambled egg patty and sausage containing chicken, while the McDonald’s sandwich has a whole egg and a different sausage.
Was the taste test a blind or scientific comparison?
The supplied report describes a weeklong personal taste test but does not say it was blind or conducted using a formal scoring method. Its findings are the reviewer’s own impressions.
Source: rss
Columbus Day / Indigenous Peoples' Day Picks
long weekend sales
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
